Having trouble viewing the email and images? View the email online.

A Golfing Journey

Friday 3 May 2024

 

Dear Derren

As we embark upon another, significant chapter in the history of Huntingdale Golf Club, it gives us pause to reflect upon the trials and tribulations of a golf club that, in some shape of form, has been in existence for some 114 years.  Having traced the early history of Huntingdale Golf through the wilds of Box Hill, via the Middleborough Golf Club and the Box Hill Golf Club, we left our golfers still with the desire for, but nowhere to play, the noble game.  The story continues.

Finding a Home

The Box Hill GC survived World War 1, was wound up in 1919 due to lack of numbers (and as a result, lack of finance), but reformed for a brief period in 1923 before losing the course to developers.

This might have signaled the end of the story, but a determined group of golfers and sportsmen decided to crack on, among them Dr. Benjamin Richards, a GP with consulting rooms in Box Hill, and Charles Valentine Browne, a former Wimmera District golf champion who, at the age of 32, returned to his birthplace, Melbourne, and opened a chemist store in Station Street, Box Hill.

Funnily enough Dr. Richards apparently had no real interest in golf up until this time, but he was a keen sportsman and, more to the point, was very community minded. Browne, on the other hand, was a scratch marker who was president of the Dimboola GC when the opportunity arose for him to move back to Melbourne.

Led by these two stalwarts, the 'homeless' ball strikers set about finding a new place to play, and soon after entered into negotiations with Mrs Julia Stutt, who owned the property known as Tullamore, on Doncaster Road, Doncaster, with a view to acquiring a lease on some of her land. The Stutts were a prominent Melbourne family, with Mrs. Stutt's late husband, William Stutt, having been a hotelier and Member of Parliament,

Tullamore had an interesting history. It was established in 1886 by leading surgeon, Dr Thomas Fitzgerald who, when knighted in 1897, became the first Australian to be so honoured for eminence in the medical profession.

A keen racing man Fitzgerald was surgeon to the Victoria Racing Club for many years, and attained a world-wide reputation as a starter, dropping the flag on the Melbourne Cup each year until well into the 1890's.

He also possessed an imposing art collection, including Jules Lefebvre's nude study 'Chloe'. Upon Fitzgerald's death the painting was sold, and in 1909 its new owner chose to exhibit it in the saloon bar of Young & Jackson's Hotel on the corner of Flinders St and Swanston St. It has remained there ever since, and is considered one of Melbourne's most famous cultural icons.

The original Tullamore property encompassed 76 acres of hilly pasture land, and on the most elevated section, near Doncaster Road, Fitzgerald built a two-storey, 12 room brick mansion that would eventually become the Eastern GC clubhouse. The following year, in 1887 Fitzgerald built a coach house 100 or so metres down the hill, which upon the establishment of the golf club, was nicknamed the 'Elephant House", and served as the machinery shed.

club image

The Tullamore Homestead on Doncaster Road

Successful in their negotiations with Mrs. Stutt, the group organised a meeting on May, 1924, to incorporate the Box Hill GC. Some 57 Box Hill golfers and friends voted to form a committee, with Richards as president, and Browne as captain. The assets of the old club were taken over, and it was decided in its new incarnation it would be known as Eastern Golf Club.

Keen to make up for lost time the committee immediately set about building a course, aided in no small way by Tullamore's gardener, a tall, powerfully-built Englishman in his 40's named Sam Berriman, who was no stranger to golf and golf courses, having had some involvement with Riversdale GC in the early 1900's.

They worked quickly and, it seems, with some ruthlessness. The owners of livestock which still grazed upon the site, were told to remove them within seven days, otherwise they would be impounded.

But even with the cattle gone things apparently didn't move quickly enough for the committee and so, with the opening day already locked in, it was decided to go with nine temporary holes. Thus on June 14, 1924, with much pomp and ceremony, the Eastern GC was officially opened by none other than Australia's then Prime Minister, Mr (later Viscount) Stanley Bruce. It goes without saying he loved golf.

club image

Eastern Golf Club Opening

That night the club held a Gala Ball at the Hawthorn Town Hall. Both functions received wide coverage in the Melbourne press, in direct contrast to the quiet, almost unheralded opening of Huntingdale GC two decades later.

Adrian Redmond was a young man studying Law at Melbourne University when he joined Eastern in 1926, and was among those who moved across to Huntingdale in 1941. His recollections of Eastern's beginings and its surrounds at Doncaster, make for interesting reading.

"In those days there were scarcely any houses in the area, and Doncaster was a village, comprising a small, decrepit hotel and a couple of shops on the corner of Doncaster Road and Station Street (now Tram Road). The rest was mainly rural land; mostly orchards but also a few dairy farms."

Redmond claims that not long after Eastern GC came into existence, a good number of members mounted a push for the club's name to be changed yet again, this time to Tullamore, in recognition of the property upon which the club was built.

They garnered enough attention for the club to call a general meeting, to discuss the matter. "Feelings ran rather high," wrote Redmond, "with some members claiming the name Eastern gave the impression of the club being for Chinese, while others reckoned Tullamore was the name for a dirty old bog in Ireland. In the end the majority decided to adhere to Eastern."

Redmond says that when he joined the club, there were still only 12 holes, and only six completed greens. "The remaining six greens were what one would now call temporary greens - parts of the fairway mown very low, and very hard to putt on". It seems the permanent greens were still undergoing construction by Sam Berriman, but Redman wrote it wasn't long before they too came into play.

"Neither was it long before an area of land on the north-west corner of the course was bought, and a further three holes built, so making it a 15 hole course. And it remained that way for quite a long time," was Redmond's recollection.

He wrote that, after playing the 15th hole, the Eastern golfers would walk past the clubhouse to the first tee, and play the first three holes again, to complete the 18. Records seem to indicate it was some four or five years after Eastern opened, that the 18-hole course was completed.

It should be pointed out that back then the standard score on each hole, which today is referred to as par, was instead known as 'bogey'.  The bogey rating of golf holes was a popular method of setting a standard and assessing a player's performance, and was based on the playing characteristics of each hole in the early days of golf.

The fictitious "Colonel Bogey" was a low handicap player who usually made a four on a long par-three holes, and five on long par-five holes, but otherwise played nearly flawless golf. It wasn't until the late 1920's that par ratings, a more standardised system set around yardages, began to replace bogey ratings.

Details of the early courses at Doncaster are somewhat vague, but in reporting a round played by the 1921 Australian Open champion, Arthur Le Fevre, in a tournament at Eastern in 1930, The Age published the bogey rating for each of the 18 holes.

The front nine had just one bogey three hole, and four rated as five, and read as thus: 4,4,5,4,4,3,5,5,5 - 39. The back nine had three bogey threes, and four rated at five: 5,5,3,4,3, 5,3,4,5 - 37. Total: 76.

In his descriptions of the course as he played it, Redmond makes mention of Koonung Creek, which he says "meandered across the course from east to west." It figured prominently on a number of holes, not the least the 'bogey' three 14th, which Redmond said took the line of the creek bed, to a green perched above it. "In winter the creek bed became a stream, and sometimes a mass of mud resembling quicksand, so no matter how positive one was as to the spot where a mishit shot entered the mud, the ball was almost invariably lost."

And what were the balls, you might ask. Says Redmond, "the balls we used were Dunlops at 25 cents (2/6) and their cheaper grade, Warwicks, at 15 cents (1/6). Silver Kings also cost 25 cents, and the South British Rubber Co. marketed balls with the markings of the suits of playing cards, Hearts, Diamonds, Spades and Clubs. The latter balls went further, but had the disadvantage of a very soft cover, and one misguided hit could render one's ball useless with a cut in the cover".

club image

Samples of the above mentioned old golf balls

Riding a world-wide wave of popularity in golf in the 1920's, and despite the rough and hilly nature of the course, Eastern went from strength to strength. While several new clubs had been born on the Sandbelt, including Victoria and Commonwealth, there were very few courses in the north-eastern suburbs until after World War 2.

In 1925 Eastern announced that "J. (Jim) Linquist, of the Melbourne Sports Depot, has been appointed to his first club job. From all accounts he is a fine specimen of a young professional, and has made himself quite popular with those with whom his business has brought him in to contact."

Three years after the arrival of Linquist, the Eastern GC inaugurated an event which very quickly blossomed into one of the biggest tournaments held annually in Melbourne, and well and truly put the club on the golfing map.

Support for Australian servicemen was strong among golf clubs during World War 1, and it continued in the aftermath. In 1920 a number of Sydney golf clubs combined to conduct an ex-servicemens golf day, at which they played for the Australian Infantry Forces (AIF) Cup.

The success of this tournament eventually came to the notice of the Eastern GC committee, and so they initiated the AIF Cup in Victoria in 1928, an event which did for Eastern what, some 50 years later, the Australian Masters did for Huntingdale.

While other clubs followed suit, it was the tournament at Eastern, played on the Melbourne Show Day public holiday in late September, that quickly became the pre-eminent AIF Cup in Victoria, certainly in the period prior to World War 2.

The inaugural event attracted a field of 100 players, which included golfers from all over Melbourne, as well as a handful from as far away as Mildura, and from across Bass Strait. Fittingly it was won by an Eastern member, W.J.Boylan, with a round of 70.

The first AIF Cup at Eastern was for amateurs only, but the following year it became the first ex-servicemens' tournament in Australia to include professional golfers who'd served their country, among them Le Fevre. All in all 150 players stepped up to the tee, but the 'train' was off and running.

Two hundred and twenty-five entries were received for the 1930 AIF Cup which, at the time, was believed to be a record entry for a single event in Victoria, but this was easily surpassed the following year when 340 hit off, one of them being Ivo Whitton, the only man other than Greg Norman to have won five Australian Open championships.

club image

Top Photo - Ivo Whitton teeing off the first in the 1935 AIF Cup

Bottom Left Photo - Rations for the day arriving

In 1932 a special competition was added for those who'd lost limbs in the various conflicts, and the overall numbers continued to climb. 505 players hit off in 1933, and in 1934 they ran buses every hour from outside the Ball and Welch building in Flinders Street to cater for some 567 entries.

As we know the game of golf is a tough assignment at the best of times, but the pranks and diversions employed all over Eastern on AIF Cup day were akin to going to war, which is exactly what they were meant to be, so much so they attracted the attention of Melbourne's daily papers.

The Argus noted "sand bags firmly embedded on the windward side of the club veranda sheltered a free bar, but there was another of these "buckshee wet canteens" situated in a much more strategic spot - at the 12th tee. The presence of this latter post provided what the French army communiques used to refer to as a 'point d'appui' (a location where troops are assembled prior to battle), and gave rise to frequent incidents which made or marred many a drive".

Of the 1933 tournament, The Argus wrote, "There were no "galleries" following the players. Those who were not playing golf were interested principally in the revival of traditional AIF games".

club image

The 1933 AIF Cup at Eastern Golf Club.  As pictured in The Australian.

Photos of the day ran in The Australasian, one of them featuring a bi-plane which flour bombed the golfers as they went about their business. Their golf scribe wrote, "The last of the players came in at dusk. They had aped war for a day. Their surroundings had all the incongruity of a war-swept country side. Tin hats and sandbagged ramparts contrasted with blossoming orchards beyond the links. The bombing "strafe" was realistic. It was magnificent, for it was not war."

The numbers continued to grow, and the Melbourne Herald's legendary golf writer, Jack Dillon, wrote that the entry of 625 for the 1937 AIF Cup at Eastern was a world record.

On this particular day the club earned another quite extraordinary distinction. According to The Age, participants could enjoy the distinction of using the first field post office to be conducted in Australia. "Housed in one of the latest type postal vans, resplendent in post office red, telegraph, telephone and all postal facilities, with the exception of money-order business, will be available. A public telephone, complete with cabinet, will be included in the equipment.

"It is the intention of the Eastern club to issue postcards similar to those provided for members of the AIF during the Great War. The value of these cards will be enhanced in the philatelist's eye by local posting, as they will thus receive the special post mark of the first field post office. The office will be open for business from 9 am to 6 pm."

club image

Field Post Office located at Eastern Golf Club

There was no end to it. Dillon reported boy scouts being posted as fore-caddies, at points where balls could be lost. One, it seems, was a bit too keen. According to Dillon, "three balls landed in quick succession near where he was standing. Before the quartet left the tee, he rushed up to them, and, out of breath, gasped, 'Here are the three of them, misters'."

The 1939 AIF Cup was held September 28, just 27 days after the invasion of Poland by German forces on September 1 that would precipitate the Second World War. The organisers had intended to limit the field to 500, but in the knowledge that it might be the last AIF Cup in the foreseeable future, the number was increased to allow 570 ex-servicemen, including 24 limbless men who played 9-holes for a separate trophy, to step onto the tee.

When the War ended, in 1945, Huntingdale was four years into its existence, and a second version of the AIF Cup began there in 1946.

Quite obviously the AIF Cup each year took an enormous amount of organising, and it's interesting to note that among those behind the highly successful renewals in the years leading up to World War 2, were men who were instrumental in orchestrating the club's move from Doncaster to Oakleigh.

Predominate among them were Eastern's manager, and later Huntingdale's first manager, Joe Kingsley, Lou Wathen, club captain at Eastern, later Huntingdale's first president, and Jock Walker, who succeeded Wathen as Huntingdale's president.

During the 1930's Eastern boasted a number of first class players, among them multiple club champion Ron Harris, and Basil Mogg, who was just 16 when he won the club championship in 1933. But Eastern's most celebrated  golfers in its first 16 years were to be found in the women's ranks, and two of them went on to achieve recognition Australia-wide and beyond.

club image

Nell Hutton at the 1933 Marrum Cup

club image

Burtta Cheney

Nell Hutton (later Smithett) led the Eastern team to win the prestigious Marrum Cup at Barwon Heads in 1935, and in 1937 she won the Victorian Womens Amateur Championship. A member of the winning Marrum Cup team was 18 year-old Burtta Cheney, who the same year won the Victorian Womens' Junior Championship.

club image

Marrum Cup Honour Board at Barwon Heads GC

Both women lent strong voices to the push to relocate Eastern to Oakleigh, and we will see later in this series that, as members of Huntingdale, they rose to become highly respected golf administrators at club, state and national level.

Talk of buying instead of leasing land for Eastern GC started circulating early in 1936, and when it became apparent that there was little chance of being able to purchase the holding from Mrs. Stutt, the prospect of moving elsewhere loomed even more strongly.

We will have to wait for the next instalment to examine how the move was accomplished, but the die was perhaps cast when, in March, 1937, a prominent member of Eastern, on his own initiative, put down a £5 deposit on a scrubby tract of land adjacent to the Metropolitan Golf Club in Oakleigh.

*NOTE:  Many thanks to Eastern Golf Club member Ian Monks, whose comprehensive history, "One Hundred and Fifteen Years of Eastern Golf Club", provided much of the information for this article.

Brian Meldrum - Commemorative History Update Sub-Committee


HUNTINGDALE GOLF CLUB
www.huntingdalegolf.com.au
Windsor Avenue, Oakleigh South, VIC 3167

P: (03) 9579 4622
E: info@huntingdalegolf.com.au

 

facebook